For the last two weeks, our parent bloggers with kids with special needs have been putting the Social Skill Builder “My Community” software to the test. Created by two speech and language pathologists, this computer software is aimed at assisting kids 5 - 15 with generalizing their social skills outside of the school setting. Utilizing various real life community and neighborhood scenarios, this computer program (such as Autism, Asperger’s syndrome, and other spectrum disorders) addresses a variety of skill areas, including life skills, social skills, communication, and conversation.
Parents felt that the software helped open up dialog about specific issues, even for kids who weren’t diagnosed with a spectrum disorder. And because social skills have some many different nuances (it’s not like teaching the ABCs) the parents appreciated having this resource, particularly since it utilized real life scenarios. Plus, most kids are exposed to these skills in school and need assistance working on them in natural settings.
While the cost may be prohibitive for some families, if you’re spending money on therapy (or have these goes in your child’s IEP), a program like this can really help facilitate growth and provide you with the support you need outside of those settings.
As a music therapist for many years, I worked extensively with children with special needs. And most often we were working together to improve their social skills and life skills. Parents with children with special needs, including developmental disabilities, sensory disorders, and autism spectrum disorders are usually quite proactive in working with their health care professional to improve on those goals when the kids are out of school, and Social Skill Builder does just that. Socialization and making friends can be quite challenging, particularly when kids are removed from their familiar and structured environments.
Their computer software “My Community” is aimed at kids 5-15 with special needs and assists them in addressing a myriad of issues regarding social interaction outside of the classroom setting. It takes what they might have learned or are currently learning, and assists them in applying it to larger settings, like their community and neighborhood. Skills such as personal safety, waiting turns, working cooperatively, and frustration management (just to name a few) are addressed in this social skills software program.
Ten of our parents bloggers with children with various special needs agreed to try this software with their kids over the last few weeks and will be sharing their experiences on their blog.
If you’re interested in learning more, please visit these blogs throughout the next two weeks and check out the Social Skill Builder website and their free demo of the software.
“I think it boils down to a feeling of betrayal. You trust your child’s doctor to know what is best for your child. You trust the medical researchers to do their jobs and release safe medicines/vaccines. You trust your government to provide adequate oversight to protect you and your family.”
More than a few bloggers have reached this same conclusion regarding the overwhelming fears and sadness surrounding autism and the still hotly-debated autism-vaccine link, which is the subject of Dr. Paul Offit’s latest book, Autism’s False Prophets.
Most of us either know a child with autism or have a child on the spectrum ourselves. On the other hand, most of us have parents or grandparents who knew children or had children who were crippled by polio or who struggled with complications of measles, mumps, rubella, or whooping cough.
They welcomed the advent of vaccinations. We fear them, or delay them, or avoid them altogether.
One blogger writes about the dichotomy behind this feeling of betrayal, breaking down in clear terms what has become clouded by emotion:
“There’s no doubt that the medical establishment has failed to own up to its own role in engendering public mistrust. Doctors often speak with frustration, and not a little condescension, about those average folks who choose rumor and wives tales over cold hard facts, but they forget how often average folks have seen cold hard facts reversed by doctors themselves, and how often they’ve seen statistically significant studies contradict each other.”
“So parents can be forgiven for thinking that not vaccinating their children is the more conservative route. But Autism’s False Prophets makes it clear that the great predominance of evidence suggests that there is no link between vaccines and autism, and that not vaccinating your child, far from being a conservative option, puts him or her at great risk. It’s hard, after all, to find a doctor who doesn’t vaccinate his kids, and this book makes a strong argument as to why.”
The gist of what Offit continues to fight against: Scientific studies and the evidence they produce are placed on par with personal anecdotes. As one blogger notes: “Offit is concerned - as am I - that lately our culture is one in which belief, or faith, in something is perceived to be as valuable as, and perhaps more valuable than, scientific evidence.”
Another blogger’s review illustrates that concern perfectly. She writes: “I said above: I’m not a scientist. But the general negativity of this book made me glad that I’m not a scientist. I prefer hope.” She wanted to believe Offit’s words, but “his condescending tone made me want to side with the people he was mocking. His general air of superiority really put me off. And his total lack of hope for parents and children dealing with autism left me feeling, well, hopeless.” Despite how Offit strives to demonstrate the science behind his conclusions - or perhaps because of how he does so - emotion gets in the way and clouds the points he seeks to make.
They’re good points, too. This blogger reports: “The crux of the issue is that autistic symptoms are often first observed in children in their second year of life - which is precisely the time that they receive many of their immunizations against childhood diseases. This is a coincidence, pure and simple. But frantic parents, desperate to understand why their toddlers are withdrawing from the socioemotional arena, cast about for anything that might bear on the often alarmingly sudden appearance of autistic behaviors in their kids. (Twenty percent of children with autism develop typically and then regress during the second year of life - with little or no warning.)” Another notes that “Recent studies are now making it clear that the cause of autism is genetic - but identifying the genes will not necessarily make treatment easier because it seems to be related to many genes. Two incurable diseases, cystic fibrosis and sickle cell anemia, are tied to one gene. Autism is much more complex.” Much more progress must be made in order to answer those nagging questions and assuage those lingering doubts.
Dr. Offit continues to work toward that end, in spite of the way his words can be received and the opposition they can generate. “Offit brings light to the bad science that seems to surround this debate. Whenever emotions get intertangled with science, more times than not, you end up with bad science,” states one blogger. Another agrees: “He made me realize how easy it is to be swayed by the moving stories of individual parents, but their stories are not science.”
Dr. Offit will donate all royalties from the sales of Autism’s False Prophets to autism research.
Thanks to all of our bloggers who took the time to read this book and write such thoughtful reviews. Thanks also to the commenters, both here and on their individual posts. The randomly drawn winner of a copy of Autism’s False Prophets is Liz, from Flint Family. Please email us to claim your prize!
“…it’s one of those amazingly controversial topics - like abortion, religion, and the current election - that can shut a friendly conversation down fast.”
That statement perfectly sums up the autism-vaccine link.
When we queried bloggers for interest in reading and reviewing Autism’s False Prophets, Dr. Paul A. Offit’s most recent book, the mention of the book itself - even just its title - provoked strong reactions. It seems many parents hold very strong opinions regarding the autism-vaccine link - some based on personal experience, some based on their reading of peer-reviewed research studies and other books (such as Offit’s previous book, Vaccinated, also reviewed here at PBN), and some based on pop culture.
Dr. Offit “has spent his career focusing on vaccines, immunology and virology, and the book is the doctor’s attempt to set the record straight on the topic of vaccines and autism. He says there’s no connection between the two, and he has a lot of scientific research to back that up.”
This blogger notes how Offit focuses on disproving that connection: “While Offit is clearly on the side of “vaccines do not cause autism,” his book looks at the research that was given to the contrary. He spends pages highlighting the opposing research, even devoting whole chapters (”Lighting the Fuse,” “Mercury Rising”) to the story that vaccines cause autism. Each time, however, Offit provides damning evidence to the contrary. No respected medical establishment believes that vaccines cause autism.” Another blogger elaborates further regarding how Autism’s False Prophets describes “the few physicians and researchers that were behind these myths were doing research in their basements (p. 135) not at accredited facilities, casting scientific method aside and falsifying data which would later be criticized by the AAP, IOM, CDC and academic institutions.”
But it’s the consequences of these questionable studies and the purported treatments and cures that are of even greater concern: “The court cases, the conspiracy theories, the death threats, the high profile individuals, the risky treatments for autistic children - all are part of the controversy. And unfortunately, an entire cottage industry of litigation lawyers, advocacy groups, and unethical doctors have taken advantage of parents who are looking for a cause for autism.” This blogger adds: “These treatments had parents of autistic children digging deep into their pockets, giving them hope of a cure. None of the children were ‘cured’ and some of them were even harmed in the process.”
One of the most powerful blogger reviews was written by a mother whose daughter is deaf:
“What’s wrong with a little alternative medicine? I’m a big fan of chiropractic medicine, music therapy and other things considered outside the mainstream. But many parents of autistic children are not only suckered in to expensive, needless therapies, but may end up inadvertently killing their child.”
“Early intervention works. It won’t cure your child of autism, but it can show amazing improvement.”
“I’m not saying it won’t be a fight, but that is where you should put your energies, not unproven, harmful interventions. Get your child occupational therapy, speech therapy, music therapy - anything that is research based and medically proven to help.”
Dr. Offit’s passion for the topic is undeniable, and his emotion sometimes overshadows his message, leading to “an unnecessary snarky remark here and there.” One blogger warned: “The vitriol with which he goes after his targets – researchers, the media, tort lawyers and activist parents – betrays his passion and bias on the topic. I understand his anger, but I think those who truly believe that vaccinations might injure their babies will find it off-putting.” But the first blogger went on to advise: “If you don’t agree with the book’s premise, well, keep your friends close and your enemies closer…read it as an atheist would read the Bible.”
Dr. Offit continues to proceed with his research and writing despite sometimes violent opposition: “Offit knows his work has consequences. He starts the prologue by quoting some of the more colorful hate mail he has received. Having my own children, I cannot fathom how difficult it must be to parent one with special needs. I can imagine that these parents, in moments of desperation, are just looking for someone to blame. Many choose Offit as their target, and while this could lead to risks to himself and his family, he presses on. Why? Because he believes he is doing the right thing.”
Regardless of which side parents take in this polarizing debate, it’s for certain that our supreme goal is to care for our children. “In an age when we are all trying to do the best for our children, when we aren’t entirely sure who to believe, I found the book and all the statistical evidence that it provides as a great reassurance that vaccines do not cause autism. Furthermore, rather than spending money and resources fighting against vaccines, we should be focusing on what does cause autism and how we can support those who are affected by it.”
To this end, Dr. Offit will donate all royalties from sales of Autism’s False Prophets to autism research.
More reviews of Autism’s False Prophets are coming up.
Last year, fifteen of our bloggers read and reviewed Dr. Paul A. Offit’s book Vaccinated. Now Offit is back with a new book, Autism’s False Prophets, that takes on the fallout of the publicity surrounding the still-unproven link between vaccinations and autism.
Offit is the chief of Infectious Diseases and the director of the Vaccine Education Center at the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, as well as the Maurice R. Hilleman Professor of Vaccinology and professor of pediatrics at the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine. He’s also the coinventor of the rotavirus vaccine RotaTeq.
In Autism’s False Prophets, Offit covers the alternative therapies that have been developed to “treat” autism and the unintended harm that they have caused. He also lays out the history of autism research and the opportunism and exploitation surrounding the anti-vaccination publicity of recent years.
Dr. Offit will donate all royalties from sales of Autism’s False Prophets to autism research.
Ten of our bloggers will read and review Autism’s False Prophets - several of whom also read and reviewed Vaccinated. Check out their upcoming reviews:
WIN IT! If you’d like to win a copy of Autism’s False Prophets, leave a comment here or on the upcoming Mid-Campaign post. We’ll draw one winner at random and announce on the Round-Up!
Five of our bloggers reviewed two different social-skills DVDs aimed at children on the autistic spectrum. Skill Building Buddies: Handling Transitions and Change focuses on coping with routine changes and other unexpected disappointments. Kibbles Rockin’ Clubhouse, Volume One: Expressing Yourself teaches greetings, “using your words,” identifying emotions, and saying goodbye. Both DVDs emphasized the need to stay calm. This is reassuring to our reviewers, as one of the challenges for parents of children on the spectrum is finding ways to cope with tantrums, funny noises, and other outlets of frustration that are considered inappropriate in standard social circles.
Skill-Building Buddies: Handling Transitions and Change from Mazzarella Media focuses on unexpected schedule changes, handling disappointment, and the introduction of an unfamiliar activity. Project consultants for this DVD include psychologists, educational professionals, and speech & language pathologists.
Kibbles Rockin’ Clubhouse from NoteAbilities is a series developed by parents and experts in speech and music therapy. Our Bloggers reviewed Volume One: Expressing Yourself. This DVD covers common greetings, eye-contact, identifying emotions, and appropriate physical contact.
New parents are showered with gifts such as alphabet blocks and activity mats with bright colors and alphanumeric graphics. Simple puzzles to learn shapes and colors abound, as do every product imaginable with letters and numbers. Television shows, DVDs, electronic toys, and activity cubes aimed at infants through preschoolers all center around the “basics:” ABC’s, 123’s, colors, and shapes.
But what about social skills?
Until recently, most people assumed that social skills were naturally learned, whereas the more “academic” subjects had to be taught. But with the increasing number of diagnoses of autistic spectrum disorders and similar conditions where effective communication and coping strategies can be challenged, tutoring for social skills has become more prevalent. Fortunately, this need has propagated into the at-home market.
Five of our bloggers had the opportunity to try two DVDs aimed at kids on the autistic spectrum:
Skill-Building Buddies: Handling Transitions and Change from Mazzarella Media focuses on unexpected schedule changes, handling disappointment, and the introduction of an unfamiliar activity. Project consultants for this DVD include psychologists, educational professionals, and speech & language pathologists.
Leave a comment on this post or on the round-up post (4/28) and you will be entered to win – one lucky winner will receive both DVDs! <strong>Congratulations to Jen G, winner of the DVDs!
In the meantime, find out what the parents thought:
Our bloggers are directed to write frank and honest reviews assessing their personal experience with a product or service. Their reviews may include both positive and negative feedback.
For more information, please refer to our Disclaimer.